This may surprise many of our listeners and supporters, but I no longer attend church. I was raised in a Christian household and then became the daughter of a minister when my father changed careers and was ordained in the Methodist denomination. At first, this transition didn’t feel much different given we spent multiple days of the week at church for various activities before he became a minister. Seeing him in the pulpit each Sunday filled me with a certain pride in my elementary years, but things really started to shift when I reached middle school and high school. Church stopped being enjoyable and I felt a lot of pressure from congregants who expected the pastor’s family to look, sound, act, be a certain way. I still loved seeing my father preach, and yet the totality of the experience at church grew more and more painful. Through a series of painful events, by the time I was entering college* I wanted to put not just church but all of Christianity behind me. Long story short, I had to go through a crisis of faith as a young adult and came out the other side much stronger and confident in my beliefs, and with the clarity that ‘church’ was not a necessary component of my faith journey anymore.
I share this bit of autobiography to let interfaithing families know that questioning and even challenging parts of your religious upbringing is totally fine. One might even say it’s encouraged! For many Christians and-or those who were raised with Christian traditions, attending church is a big deal. Especially within the context of being in the United States and the history of this country being bound together with a great shift within Christianity itself, whether or not you go to church has been deeply engrained in our society and culture. Recently, religious identity and religious practice have shifted dramatically. Just look at the numerous Pew Research studies on the topic and scores of other articles over the past 15 years, it is obvious that something is changing…and we’re not quite sure collectively what it means.
Many Christians and certainly the denominations themselves express concern about this rise of disaffiliation and non-attendance at church, but I see a great opportunity. And for interfaithers, your (potential) role in this area of dialogue about Christian practices is exciting and rich. Have you ever experienced attending church as compulsory or conditional? As if, by not attending, people would notice and then judge you? Or, by attending, but you do something ‘the wrong way,’ people will also notice and then judge you? Have you really asked yourself, why am I going to church? A rote answer might be, because Jesus commanded it, and I would mostly agree. Jesus also commanded people to love, and to follow the Golden Rule, to love one’s neighbors, and to care for teh stranger, the sick, the orphaned, and the lost. The sad truth for so many throughout Christian history is that church becomes a place where they have been turned away or cast out.
Interfaith families, as well as anyone who feels called to step outside their comfort zone, have a unique opportunity to say to church: “We’re here… deal with it!” Not in an abrasive way, but with the mindset of a seeker, a sojourner, a traveler on their faith journey who is still interested in community as well as stretching what it means to be church! There is enormous potential in the commandment to gather together and honor Jesus’ teaching and influence, and churches need not confine themselves to narrow definitions of what that means and who is welcomed. As an interfaither, if you find yourself facing the uncomfortable experience of being viewed as ‘wrong’ or the sense of “you’ll be accepted here, but only if…”, maybe do what Jesus told his disciples and dust the dirt off your sandals and walk away. Or, press the question. Raise the challenge. Make your voice known.
My father and I were taking theology and politics recently, and he reminded me of an important point: in the Book of Revelations, as the Second Coming is being described, what brings about this event is that the Church has failed. In our world today, is church an example of humanity at its best, or is there always room for improvement? There are myriad ways to explore one’s faith and form community, and interfaithers can be called into the space of promoting growth from within or from a distance.
*For an even deeper dive on this part of my story, I authored a chapter in the book “Kissing the Chapel, Praying in the Frat House.”